Making Your Directory Stand Out
If you have visited any SEO forum which allows people to announce new directories, you may have noticed there is a new one created approximately every 1.3 seconds. This has been the case for a couple of years and I don’t anticipate it slowing down any time soon. As many directories as there are popping up each day, there are still forum posters asking if it’s worth it to start one. Usually if you have to ask, then the answer is no but for those of us that have decided to take the plunge, there are a few things you can do to distinguish yourself.
The following is my checklist. It has changed since the days I started Kwik Goblin which was really a toe in the water for me. I later sold that site on and the new owner has done a great job developing it. I started my Business Directory a few months ago using the following guidelines and it is doing quite well getting around 120 submissions a day.
Make your Directory SE Friendly
There is some disagreement on what aspects truly make it SE friendly but one of the biggest is to make sure submitters get a direct link to their site. Be careful not to use redirects, no follows, or other things which can sometimes come as standard in some directory scripts. I also use Mod Rewrite to create what appear to be static pages although I would agree with those that say they don’t make the directory SEO friendly, but as you will see in many of the tips in this post, perception is sometimes as important as reality.
Make Your Directory User Friendly
This was a huge mistake most directories made in the early days. They required users to jump through hoops in order to submit a site for consideration. This could include setting up an account, confusing image verification and double email confirmations. SPAM is the directory owners responsibility to stop and putting the burden on the visitor will only affect the quality of submissions you receive. There are plenty of methods for combating spammers and your visitors can be none the wiser. Also be sure that your navigation is intuitive. I see too many directory sites designed around AdSense rather then the user. If you are after the quick profit then there is probably no changing your mind but personally I believe AdSense is a waste of time if you have less then 1000 uniques a day on a directory site.
Submit Your Directory to Directories
The title says it all. With so many directories around you can’t expect people to find you. In addition to directory submissions, you should post announcing your directory in every forum you can find (and allows it). I would also contact those offering directory submission services and get them to add your directory to their submission list. It will take a while to gain momentum but once you do you could be seeing several hundred submissions a day
There are of course many more specific tips which I may decide to share over the next few weeks. In general, if you are deciding whether to add a new directory, I would suggest picking a specific niche. General directories are a dime a dozen and that means they are a lot harder to market. On the of the more successful ones recently has been Alive Directory but I know that the owner of that directory has a 5 figure budget which he has spent very wisely. If you don’t have the cash to spare, I would suggest carving out your own piece of the market by either offering some niche that hasn’t been catered to or pick an existing niche and do it better.
Comment by Perrow
Posted on July 5, 2006 at 12:43 pm
Why is it your tips/tutorials always include so much work? If I wanted to work that hard I wouldn’t be in the internet bussiness now, would I
Comment by Jason
Posted on July 5, 2006 at 12:48 pm
Its a lot more work writing about it…lol. I have a lot more suggestions but I am having trouble writing them all in a coherent way without distractions
I will blog about it when its done but there will soon be a link on every listing in the Business Directory where you can Sponsor any link. That means no need to resubmit if you decide you want top position (and top exposure)
Comment by mad4
Posted on July 5, 2006 at 1:10 pm
With so many directories trying to make money simply from being a directory its nice to see a directory that sits on the back of a site and is designed to complement it rather than stand alone.
Making money on a directory must be nearly impossible. Monetizing a site that has a useful directory on it is easy (not that this site is designed to make money but you know what I mean!).
Comment by Perrow
Posted on July 5, 2006 at 3:24 pm
How long would you say you spend on the acceptance/rejection process each day (given that you actually sift through all 120 submissions)?
Nice idea with the ’sponsor this site’ link, might rip that one off on my software site.
Pingback by Bloggeries Blog Reviews » Blog Archive » Off the top of my head - yfs1.com
Posted on July 6, 2006 at 11:45 am
[…] So I didn’t plan to review this one next. Why did I? Because at my favorite webmaster forum (other than my own), I saw the title to his latest blog entry called Making Your Directory Stand Out. It appealed to me, because I’ve been running 2 directories for a while, and needless to say, directories are dime a dozen now. There are some good ones out there such as the Alive Directory, which he points out, but the vast majority doesn’t provide any value whatsoever. […]
Comment by KwikGoblin
Posted on July 14, 2006 at 4:37 pm
Jason, thanks so much for your kind words about my directory (formerly your directory
One thing I’ve found about niche directories: they’re a lot harder to make profitable. The fact is that with a general directory, your market is anywhere from say 10 to 100 times larger than when the market for a niche directory.
That being said, I think that a niche directory attached to a niche website would do very well. But the niche directory on its own - I’ve found that to be a hard slog.
Comment by Rob
Posted on July 18, 2006 at 4:11 am
Another solid tutorial - thanks for sharing your thoughts on the subject, Jason.
“perception is sometimes as important as reality”
I would personally change the ’sometimes’ to ‘often’
SEO friendly is a key I think - I just looked at my new directory that has been laying dormant and all of the internal pages are PR4 … time to gear up and put your tutorial to use
Comment by Web Brander
Posted on July 23, 2006 at 1:08 pm
I run a few directorys all niche I find that I get a lot of general websites being submitted that don’t belong in the directory niche, how would you address that issue?
Comment by Mason
Posted on August 8, 2006 at 8:29 pm
There are millions of directors these days. Do any one really visit directories these days? , if there is search engine?